Pennsylvania's Right-to-Know Law: Gaining Access to Public Records

Prepared by: Thomas Alan Linzey, Esq.
The Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF)
Copyright 1998

Pennsylvania's Open Records Law
State Right to Know Laws

I. Introduction - How you Got Here

Public records constitute one of the only links between the operations of local and state government; and members of the general public. Easily accessing these documents makes the difference between timely activism and activism that is delayed past the point where it is effective.

You've probably arrived at this Guide because you've been denied access to certain materials and documents by a local government, State agency, or other entity. Those materials and documents may or may not be obtainable under Pennsylvania's Open Records Law (Right to Know Law), and this Guide will assist you in determining whether Pennsylvania's Open Records Law applies to those documents, and how you can request and gain access to those documents.

This Manual begins with a text copy of Pennsylvania's Open Records Law, and proceeds to a sample letter that can be used to request documents under the statute. That Letter is then followed by a step by step summary of steps that must be taken by requesting citizens to secure rights under the Law, along with a Model Complaint that can be used to sue agencies that refuse to produce public records.

As with all Manuals published by the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, Inc., users are advised to contact the Fund's staff attorney at (717) 709-0457 or at info@celdf.org if any questions arise during the use of this Manual. It is also suggested that requesters retain formal legal counsel to assist them in the use of sample legal materials within this Manual.

II. Pennsylvania's Right to Know Law

Pennsylvania's Right to Know law was overhauled in 2002 by the Pennsylvania State legislature. See Act 100 of 2002 (HB 2100), repealing Act 212 of 1957. The new Right to Know law became effective on December 26, 2002. The legislative overhaul supplanted almost all of the original Right to Know law, except for two definitions - of "agency" and "public records" - that remain in the original Right to Know law. The retaining of those definitions under the old law guarantees that prior case law construing those terms could still serve as legal precedents for Courts under the new Law.

What follows below is the actual text of Pennsylvania's "new" Right to Know law, now officially entitled the "Open Records Law". The underlined portions constitute the text that was added by the new Open Records Law to the old Right to Know law.

Pennsylvania's New Right to Know Law:
Pennsylvania's Open Records Law, Act 100 of 2002 (HB 2100)

Section 1. Definitions.

The following words and phrases when used in this act shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:

"Agency." Any office, department, board or commission of the executive branch of the Commonwealth, any political subdivision of the Commonwealth, the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, the State System of Higher Education or any State or municipal authority or similar organization created by or pursuant to a statute which declares in substance that such organization performs or has for its purpose the performance of an essential governmental function.

"Commonwealth agency." An agency which is a Commonwealth agency as that term is defined under 62 Pa.C.S. § 103 (relating to definitions).
"Non-Commonwealth Agency." An agency which is not a Commonwealth agency.

"Public record." Any account, voucher or contract dealing with the receipt or disbursement of funds by an agency or its acquisition, use or disposal of services or of supplies, materials, equipment or other property and any minute, order or decision by an agency fixing the personal or property rights, privileges, immunities, duties or obligations of any person or group of persons: Provided, That the term "public records" shall not mean any report, communication or other paper, the publication of which would disclose the institution, progress or result of an investigation undertaken by an agency in the performance of its official duties, except those reports filed by agencies pertaining to safety and health in industrial plants; it shall not include any record, document, material, exhibit, pleading, report, memorandum or other paper, access to or the publication of which is prohibited, restricted or forbidden by statute law or order or decree of court, or which would operate to the prejudice or impairment of a person's reputation or personal security, or which would result in the loss by the Commonwealth or any of its political subdivisions or commissions or State or municipal authorities of Federal funds, excepting therefrom however the record of any conviction for any criminal act.

"Record." Any document maintained by an agency, in any form, whether public or not.

"Requester." A person who is a resident of the Commonwealth and requests a record pursuant to this act.

"Response." Access to a record or an agency's written notice granting, denying or partially granting and partially denying access to a record.

Section 2. Procedure for access to public records.

(a) General rule.--Unless otherwise provided by law, a public record shall be accessible for inspection and duplication by a requester in accordance with this act. A public record shall be provided to a requester in the medium requested if the public record exists in that medium; otherwise, it shall be provided in the medium in which it exists. Public records shall be available for access during the regular business hours of an agency. Nothing in this act shall provide for access to a record which is not a public record.

(b) Requests.--Agencies may fulfill verbal requests for access to records and anonymous requests for access to records. In the event that the requester wishes to pursue the relief and remedies provided for in this act, the requester must initiate such relief with a written request.

(c) Written requests.--A written request for access to records may be submitted in person, by mail, by facsimile or, to the extent provided by agency rules, any other electronic means. A written request shall be addressed to the agency head or other person designated in the rules established by the agency. A written request should identify or describe the records sought with sufficient specificity to enable the agency to ascertain which records are being requested and shall include the name and address to which the agency should address its response. A written request need not include any explanation of the requester's reason for requesting or intended use of the records.

(d) Electronic access.--In addition to the requirements of subsection (a), an agency may make its public records available through any publicly accessible electronic means. If access to a public record is routinely available by an agency only by electronic means, the agency shall provide access to inspect the public record at an office of the agency.

(e) Creation of a public record.--When responding to a request for access, an agency shall not be required to create a public record which does not currently exist or to compile, maintain, format or organize a public record in a manner in which the agency does not currently compile, maintain, format or organize the public record.

(f) Conversion of an electronic record to paper -- If a public record is only maintained electronically or in other nonpaper media, an agency shall, upon request, duplicate the public
record on paper when responding to a request for access in accordance with this act.

(g) Retention of records - Nothing in this act is intended to modify, rescind or supersede any record retention and disposition schedule established pursuant to law.

Section 3.1. Access to public records.

An agency may not deny a requester access to a public record due to the intended use of the public record by the requester.

Section 3.2. Redaction.

If an agency determines that a public record contains information which is subject to access as well as information which is not subject to access, the agency's response shall grant access to the information which is subject to access and deny access to the information which is not subject to access. If the information which is not subject to access is an integral part of the public record and cannot be separated, the agency shall redact from the public record the information which is not subject to access and the response shall grant access to the information which is subject to access. The agency may not deny access to the public record if the information which is not subject to access is able to be redacted. Information which an agency redacts in accordance with this subsection shall be deemed a denial under section 3.3.

Section 3.3. Commonwealth agency's response to written requests for access.

(a) General rule.--Upon receipt of a written request for access to a record, a Commonwealth agency shall make a good faith effort to determine if the record requested is a public record and to respond as promptly as possible under the circumstances existing at the time of the request, but shall not exceed ten business days from the date the written request is received by the Commonwealth agency head or other person designated by the Commonwealth agency for receiving such requests. If the Commonwealth agency fails to send the response within ten business days of receipt of the written request for access, the written request for access shall be deemed denied.

(b) Exception.--Upon receipt of a written request for access, if a Commonwealth agency determines that one of the following applies:

(1) the request for access requires redaction of a public record in accordance with section 3.2;

(2) the request for access requires the retrieval of a record stored in a remote location;

(3) a timely response to the request for access cannot be accomplished due to bona fide and specified staffing limitations;

(4) a legal review is necessary to determine whether the record is a public record subject to access under this act;

(5) the requester has not complied with the Commonwealth agency's policies regarding access to public records; or

(6) the requester refuses to pay applicable fees authorized by section 7 of this act, the Commonwealth agency shall send written notice to the requester within ten business days of the Commonwealth agency's receipt of the request for access. The notice shall include a statement notifying the requester that the request for access is being reviewed, the reason for the review and a reasonable date that a response is expected to be provided. If the date that a response is expected to be provided is in excess of 30 days, following the ten business days allowed for in subsection (a), the request for access shall be deemed denied.

(c) Denial.--If a Commonwealth agency's response is a denial of a written request for access, whether in whole or in part, a written response shall be issued and include:

(1) A description of the record requested.

(2) The specific reasons for the denial, including a citation of supporting legal authority. If the denial is the result of a determination that the record requested is not a public record, the specific reasons for the agency's determination that the record is not a public record shall be included.

(3) The typed or printed name, title, business address, business telephone number and signature of the public official or public employee on whose authority the denial is issued.

(4) Date of the response.

(5) The procedure to appeal the denial of access under this act.

(d) Certified copies.--If a Commonwealth agency's response grants a request for access, the Commonwealth agency shall, upon request, provide the requester with a certified copy of the public record if the requester pays the applicable fees pursuant to section 7.

Section 3.4. Non-Commonwealth agency's response to written requests for access.

(a) General rule.--Upon receipt of a written request for access to a record, a non-Commonwealth agency shall make a good faith effort to determine if the record requested is a public record and respond to as promptly as possible under the circumstances existing at the time of the request, but shall not exceed five business days from the date the written request is received by the non-Commonwealth agency head or other person designated in the rules established by the non-Commonwealth agency for receiving such requests. If the non- Commonwealth agency fails to send the response within five business days of receipt of the written request for access, the written request for access shall be deemed denied.

(b) Exception.--Upon receipt of a written request for access, if a non-Commonwealth agency determines that one of the following applies:

(1) the request for access requires redaction of a public record in accordance with section 3.2;

(2) the request for access requires the retrieval of a record stored in a remote location;

(3) a timely response to the request for access cannot be accompanied due to bona fide and specified staffing limitations;

(4) a legal review is necessary to determine whether the record is a public record subject to access under this act;

(5) the requester has not complied with the non-Commonwealth agency's policies regarding access to public records; or

(6) the requester refuses to pay applicable fees authorized by Section 7 the non-Commonwealth agency shall send written notice to the requester within five business days of the non-Commonwealth agency's receipt of the request notifying the requester that the request for access is being reviewed, the reason for the review and a reasonable date that a response is expected to be provided. If the date that a response is expected to be provided is in excess of 30 days, following the five business days allowed in subsection (a), the request for access shall be deemed denied.

(c) Denial.--If a non-Commonwealth agency's response is a denial of a written request for access, whether in whole or in part, a written response shall be issued and include:

(1) A description of the record requested.

(2) The specific reasons for the denial, including a citation of supporting legal authority. If the denial is the result of a determination that the record requested is not a public record, the specific reasons for the agency's determination that the record is not a public record shall be included.

(3) The typed or printed name, title, business address, business telephone number and signature of the public official or public employee on whose authority the denial is issued.

(4) Date of the response.

(5) The procedure to appeal the denial of access under this act.

(d) Certified copies.--If a non-Commonwealth agency's response grants a request for access, the non-Commonwealth agency shall, upon request, provide the requester with a certified copy of the public record if the requester pays the applicable fees pursuant to section 7.

Section 3.5. Final agency determination.

(a) Filing of exceptions.--If a written request for access is denied or deemed denied, the requester may file exceptions with the head of the agency denying the request for access within 15 business days of the mailing date of the agency's response or within 15 days of a deemed denial. The exceptions shall state grounds upon which the requester asserts that the record is a public record and shall address any grounds stated by the agency for delaying or denying the request.

(b) Determination.-Unless the requester agrees otherwise, the agency head or his designee shall make a final determination regarding the exceptions within 30 days of the mailing date of the exceptions. Prior to issuing the final determination regarding the exceptions, the agency head or his designee may conduct a hearing. The determination shall be the final order of the agency. If the agency head or his designee determines that the agency correctly denied the request for access, the agency head or his designee shall provide a written explanation to the requester of the reason for the denial.

Section 4. Judicial appeal.

(a) Commonwealth agency.--Within 30 days of the mailing date of a final determination of a Commonwealth agency affirming the denial of access, a requester may file a petition for review or other document as might be required by rule of court with the Commonwealth Court.

(b) Other agency.--Within 30 days of a denial by a non-Commonwealth agency under section 3.4(c) or of the mailing date of a final determination of a non-Commonwealth agency affirming the denial of access, a requester may file a petition for review or other document as might be required by rule of court with the court of common pleas for the county where the non-Commonwealth agency's office or facility is located or bring an action in the local magisterial district. A requester is entitled to a reasoned decision containing findings of fact and conclusions of law based upon the evidence as a whole which clearly and concisely states and explains the rationale for the decisions so that all can determine why and how a particular result was reached.

(c) Notice - An agency shall be served notice of actions commenced in accordance with subsection (a) or (b) and shall have an opportunity to respond in accordance with applicable court rules.

(d) Record on appeal.--The record before a court shall consist of the request; the agency's response; the requester's exceptions, if applicable; the hearing transcript, if any; and the agency's final determination, if applicable.

Section 4.1. Court costs and attorney fees.

(a) Reversal of agency determination.--If a court reverses an agency's final determination, the court may award reasonable attorney fees and costs of litigation, or an appropriate portion thereof, to a requester if the court finds either of the following:

(1) the agency willfully or with wanton disregard deprived the requester of access to a public record subject to access under the provisions of this act; or

(2) the exemptions, exclusions or defenses asserted by the agency in its final determination were not based on a reasonable interpretation of law.

(b) Sanctions for frivolous requests or appeals.--If a court affirms an agency's final determination, the court may award reasonable attorney fees and costs of litigation, or an appropriate portion thereof, to the agency if the court finds that the legal challenge to the agency's final determination was frivolous.

(c) Other sanctions - Nothing in this act shall prohibit a court from imposing penalties and costs in accordance with applicable rules of court.

Section 5. Penalties.

(a) Summary offense.--An agency or public official who violates this act with the intent and purpose of violating this act commits a summary offense subject to prosecution by the Attorney General or the appropriate district attorney and shall, upon conviction, be sentenced to pay a fine of not more than $300 plus costs of prosecution.

(b) Civil penalty.--An agency or public official who does not promptly comply with a court order under this act is subject to a civil penalty of not more than $300 per day until the public records are provided.

Section 6. Immunity.

(a) General rule.--Except as provided in sections 4.1 and 5, and other statutes governing the release of records, no agency, public official or public employee shall be liable for civil or criminal damages or penalties resulting from compliance or failure to comply with this act.

(b) Schedules.--No agency, public official or public employee shall be liable for civil or criminal damages or penalties under this act for complying with any written public record retention and disposition schedule.

Section 7. Fee limitations.

(a) Postage.--Fees for postage may not exceed the actual cost of mailing.

(b) Duplication - Fees for duplication by photocopying, printing from electronic media or microfilm, copying onto electronic media, transmission by facsimile or other electronic means and other means of duplication must be reasonable and based on prevailing fees for comparable duplication services provided by local business entities.

(c) Certification - An agency may impose reasonable fees for official certification of copies if the certification is at the behest of the requester and for the purpose of legally verifying the public record.

(d) Conversion to paper - If a public record is only maintained electronically or in other nonpaper media, duplication fees shall be limited to the lesser of the fee for duplication on paper or the fee for duplication in the native media as provided by subsection (b) unless the requester specifically requests for the public record to be duplicated in the more expensive medium.

(e) Enhanced electronic access - If an agency offers enhanced electronic access to public records in addition to making the public records accessible for inspection and duplication by a requester as required by this act, the agency may establish user fees specifically for the provision of the enhanced electronic access, but only to the extent that the enhanced electronic access is in addition to making the public records accessible for inspection and duplication by a requester as required by this act. The user fees for enhanced electronic access may be a flat rate, a subscription fee for a period of time, a per-transaction fee, a fee based on the cumulative time of system access or any other reasonable method and any combination thereof. The user fees for enhanced electronic access must be reasonable and may not be established with the intent of effect of excluding persons from access to public records or duplicates thereof or of creating profit for the agency.

(f) Waiver of fees - An agency may waive the fees for duplication of a public record, including, but not limited to, when:

(1) The requester duplicates the public record; or

(2) the agency deems it is in the public interest to do so.

(g) Limitations - Except as otherwise provided by statute, no other fees may be imposed unless the agency necessarily incurs costs for complying with the request, and such fees must be reasonable. No fee may be imposed for an agency's review of a record to determine whether the record is a public record subject to access in accordance with this act.

(h) Prepayment.--Prior to granting a request for access in accordance with this act, an agency may require a requester to prepay an estimate of the fees authorized under this section if the fees required to fulfill the request are expected to exceed $100.

Section 8. Implementation.

(a) Requirement.--An agency shall establish written policies and may promulgate regulations necessary to implement this act.

(b) Content.--The written policies shall include the name of the office to which requests for access shall be addressed and a list of applicable fees.

(c) Prohibition.--A policy or regulation may not include any of the following:

(1) A limitation on the number of public records which may be requested or made available for inspection or duplication.

(2) A requirement to disclose the purpose or motive in requesting access to records which are public records.

(d) Posting.--The policies shall be conspicuously posted at the agency and may be made available by electronic means.

Section 9. Practice and procedure.

The provisions of 2 Pa.C.S. (relating to administrative law and procedure) shall not apply to this act.

III. Sample Request Letter Under Open Records Law

January 10, 2003

Mr. Ian Kramer, Voter Registration
Bedford County Elections Bureau
334 Milek Street
Bedford, Pennsylvania 17382

Re: Open Records Law Request for Elections Bureau Public Records
Sent Via Certified Letter Return Receipt Requested on January 10, 2003

Dear Mr. Kramer,

This letter is intended as a communication submitted under Pennsylvania's Open Records Law, 65 P.S. §66.1 et seq., as amended by Act 100 of 2002 (HB 2100).

Through this communication, I am seeking access to County records dealing with voter registration. Specifically, I am seeking the listing of registered voters maintained by the Elections Bureau which lists all registered voters in East Providence Township, Bedford County as of January 1, 2003. I have previously been denied access to those records by you via an oral request made on January 5, 2003.

As you know, Pennsylvania's Open Records Law (formerly the "Right to Know" law) requires that every "public record" must be open for "inspection and duplication" by any requester. See §2 of the Open Records Law. Voter registration records are "public records" under the definition set forth in the Act at §66.1(2). The Bedford County Elections Bureau is an "agency" under the definition set forth in §66.1(1). See, e.g. Lewis v. Thornburgh, 68 Pa. Commw. 157, 448 A.2d 680 (1982); Hoffman v. Com. Pennsylvania Game Comm'n, 71 Pa. Commw. 99, 455 A.2d 731 (1983).

Under the Open Records Law, you have five (5) business days to comply with this request.

Through this communication, I am also requesting the right to make photocopies of the voter registration records at a reasonable cost. As you may know, agencies are required to allow the public to make photocopies of public records for a reasonable cost not to exceed the actual cost of reproduction. See Baravordeh v. Borough Council of Prospect Park, 699 A.2d 789 (Commw. 1997); §7(b) of the Open Records Law.

Your immediate attention to this matter is appreciated.

________________________
Thomas Linzey
2244 Lindsay Lot Road
Shippensburg, PA 17257

cc: Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF)
Thomas Alan Linzey, Esq.

IV. The Process of Obtaining Records Under Pennsylvania's Open Records Law

There are thus several stages to obtaining documents and other records under Pennsylvania's new Open Records Law, if the agency continues to refuse to release those documents for public inspection and duplication. Those steps are outlined in summary format below:

Step One: Requesting Documents From An Agency.

A written request for records, using the Model Letter provided by this Manual, should always be submitted as the first step in requesting documents from an agency. Usually, such a step is preceded by an oral request to the agency for documents, and a refusal by the agency to accede to that oral request.

Step Two: The Agency Responds.

Under the Open Records law, the agency either has ten (10) business days - if a Commonwealth (State) agency - or five (5) business days for all other agencies, to respond formally to the request. A denial by the agency must include a description of the record requested, the specific reasons for the denial supported by case law or other precedent, the printed name, title, and address of the public official that issued the denial, the date of the response, and the procedure to appeal the denial. If the Agency approves the request, it has the discretion to establish reasonable conditions on the release of the materials - including reasonable duplication costs - and prepayment of certain costs associated with review and duplication of records.

If the Agency simply fails to respond, the exhaustion of the deadlines serves as the denial. At that point, a requester has thirty (30) days to file a Petition for Review with the appropriate Court or the District Magistrate.

Step Three: The Filing of Exceptions.

Under the new Open Records Law, there's an additional step for citizens prior to filing suit in County Court. That step involves the filing of "Exceptions" to the agency's written denial letter. Within fifteen days of the agency's response, the requester must file "Exceptions" to the agency's denial of the request. Such a submission must be made within fifteen days of the mailing date of the agency's denial. The Exceptions must state grounds upon which the requester asserts that the record is a public record, and must address the grounds upon which the agency has issued their denial.

Step Four: The Agency Responds to the Exceptions - the Final Determination.

The agency head or his/her designee then makes a "final determination" regarding the exceptions within thirty days of the mailing date of the Exceptions. Prior to issuing that final determination, the agency may conduct a hearing. The final determination shall be the final order of the agency, and if the denial is affirmed by the final determination, the agency must provide a written explanation to the requester listing the reasons for the denial.

Step Five: Suing the Agency.

Under the Open Records Law, a requester may file a petition for review in the Commonwealth Court (if a Commonwealth agency) or in the County Court of Common Pleas or in front of a District Magistrate (if a non-State agency). The law now entitles the requester to a "reasoned decision" containing findings of fact and conclusions of law. The Record reviewed by the Court or Magistrate will consist of the request, the agency's response, the requester's exceptions, and the agency's final determination. If the Court or Magistrate reverses an agency's final determination, the Court or Magistrate may award reasonable attorney fees and costs of litigation if it finds that the agency willfully refused to produce records, or that the agency's interpretation of the law was not reasonable.

A Sample Complaint that can be used in the Commonwealth Court is included with this Manual as an Appendix. With small alterations, this Complaint can be used in a County Court of Common Pleas. If pursued in front of a District Magistrate, that office will provide the Forms necessary for the appeal.

Note that under the new Law, the documents and materials generated to, and from, the agency constitute the "Administrative Record" that the Court will review. It is essential, therefore, that the requester advance all necessary arguments within those materials, to preserve those arguments and points during the appeal. Generally, no new evidence beyond the materials associated with the request and denial will be reviewed by the Court to determine whether the documents should have been released.

V. Conclusion

The new Open Records Law in Pennsylvania imposes additional duties on the requesting party that were not found within the old Right to Know law. However, the new law also imposes specific deadlines and other protections for requesters. The explicit ability to use the District Magistrate at the municipal level to obtain documents (a new element of Pennsylvania's Open Records Law) enables the requester to avoid the costs and delays associated with pursuit in the Courts of a legal determination.
If you are interested in pursuing judicial action, you are urged to contact the Fund, who will assist you as you continue your quest to obtain these documents through the courts. It is also suggested that you retain formal legal counsel to assist you with using the Courts to obtain your access to public records.

Appendix A
Model Petition for Review Under Pennsylvania's Open Records Law

IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF THE
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA

Petition for Review
Appellate Jurisdiction

I. Parties

1. Defendant Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee is a duly constituted legislative standing Committee of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, and its current Chairman is State Representative Raymond Bunt, Jr. (R-Montgomery).
   
   
2. Defendant Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee is an "Agency" under Pennsylvania's Open Records Law, 65 P.S. §66.1 et seq., as amended by Act 100 of 2002 (HB 2100).
   
   
3. Plaintiff [Requester or Requesting Organization] resides at [ ], and is a "requester" under Pennsylvania's Open Records law.
   
   
4. Plaintiffs have filed this action within thirty days from the mailing date of the final determination issued by the Commonwealth Agency which denied the Plaintiff's requests for public records under the law.
   
   
5. The Commonwealth Court has appellate jurisdiction over this action by virtue of §4(a) of Pennsylvania's Open Records Law.

   II. Statement of the Claim

6. On [Date], the Plaintiff requested, via written communication, that the Commonwealth Agency produce public records for inspection and duplication.
   
   
7. In that written request, the Plaintiff asked to inspect [Describe particular records requested].
   
   
8. On [Date], the Commonwealth Agency issued a letter to the Plaintiff, denying the Plaintiff's request for inspection of those public records.
   
   
9. In that letter, the Commonwealth Agency claimed that the sought records were exempt from the Open Records Law because [describe reasons for denial].
   
   
10. On [Date], the Plaintiff filed written Exceptions to the denial letter issued by the Commonwealth Agency.
    
    
11. On [Date], the Commonwealth Agency issued a Final Determination, denying the Plaintiff's request for inspection of those public records.
    
    
12. In that Final Determination letter, the Commonwealth Agency denied the Plaintiff's request for the following reasons: [list reasons for denial].
    
    
13. On [Date], the Plaintiff filed the instant Petition for Review, requesting that this Court reverse the Final Determination issued by the Commonwealth Agency.

    III. Count One: The Records Sought by the Plaintiff Are Public Records
    Under the Pennsylvania Open Records Law, and the Final Determination
    of the Commonwealth Agency Should be Reversed

14. The Pennsylvania House of Representatives' Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee is a standing Committee of the legislature, and is an "Agency" as defined under the Pennsylvania Open Records Law.
    
    
15. The [Description of Public Records] are "Public Records" as defined under the Pennsylvania Open Records Law.
    
    
16. The Commonwealth Agency erred in interpreting the Open Records Law as not requiring that it produce the requested records to the Plaintiff under the Law.
    
    
17. The Commonwealth Agency acted willfully or with wanton disregard in denying the Plaintiff access to the public records.
    
    
18. The Commonwealth Agency's interpretation of the Open Records Law was not based on a reasonable interpretation of the Law.

    IV. Request for Relief

19. The Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court reverse the Final Determination of the Commonwealth Agency, and order the Agency to make the requested Public Records available for inspection and duplication by the Plaintiff.
    
    
20. The Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court find that that the Agency acted in willful or wanton disregard of the Open Records Law, or that the Agency's interpretation of the Open Records Law was not a reasonable one, and accordingly, award the Plaintiff reasonable attorney fees and costs of litigation.

Respectfully Submitted this 30th Day of January, 2003

_______________________________
Thomas Alan Linzey, Esq.
Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, Inc.
2859 Scotland Road
Chambersburg, Pennsylvania 17201

IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF THE
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA

NOTICE TO DEFEND

You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.

YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.

[County Legal Referral Service]
[Address]
[Address]
[Phone Number]

Affidavit of Original Process

I, [Serving Individual], hereby swear and affirm that I am a competent adult under Rule 76 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, and that I am therefore over eighteen years of age and that I am neither a party to the action nor an employee or a relative of those parties.

I, [Serving Individual], swear and affirm that I personally hand-served the following parties on the date below:

House Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee
c/o Representative Raymond Bunt, Jr.
146 Main Capitol
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120

Attorney General Mike Fisher
16th Floor, Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120

I declare under penalty of perjury and pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1746 that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.

Executed this 30th Day of January, 2003.

__________________________
[Serving Individual]
[Address]
[Address]

Verification

The undersigned Plaintiffs, upon their personal knowledge or information and belief, hereby swear and affirm that the statements of fact within the accompanying Complaint are true and correct to the best of their knowledge.

This Verification is signed subject to 18 Pa.C.S., relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.

__________________________
[Plaintiff]
[Address]
[Address]